The inbox order
The list is sorted by what needs you, not by what arrived last. The keys, in order:
- Never answered — no outbound message at all.
- Pre-sales needing attention — a buying question nobody has handled.
- Starred — your own flag.
- Unread.
- Status — waiting on you before waiting on them.
- Priority — the classifier's reading order.
- Last activity — only as the final tie-break.
Why not newest-first
Newest-first is the order that lets an unanswered thread sink. Every day it drops a little, and the one that damages your Addons response metric is exactly the one you stop seeing. Putting "never answered" first makes that impossible.
If you want chronological
Sort by the date column. The default is a recommendation, not a cage.
Pre-sales only counts when it needs attention
A pre-sales thread you have already answered does not get the boost — otherwise answered pre-sales would bury genuinely unread rows, which is the opposite of what the boost is for.